as we already informed you:
"After you forfeit the bonus your winnings in *real* money will stay the same", hence you have been informed correctly. This was mentioned in first email which you received.
Then you asked what happens if you forfeit bonus and we explained as follows:
If you forfeit your bonus, this bonus is automatically cancelled which means that there are no more wagering requirements but you can only play with your real money (only your real money will stay in your account after a bonus cancellation, this has also been explained in our previous email).
You haven't met our bonus-money wagering requirements, nevertheless you tried to forfeit the bonus and keep your bonus-money winnings.
If this would work as you described, everyone would make a deposit, get the bonus, make some winnings and then forfeit the bonus and keep the winnings.
Also I would like to remind you that you did not place any single bet using real money, you played all the time only with your bonus funds.
Caribic Casino Support